The sudden surge in used electric vehicle (EV) demand across Australia has caught the attention of Fleet Managers and remarketing teams alike. Clearance rates are rising, selling times are shrinking, and prices are moving in the opposite direction to what many expected only 12 months ago.
But this is not the first time the automotive market has shifted rapidly in response to economic pressure. History shows that fuel price spikes and financial uncertainty have repeatedly reshaped vehicle demand—and each time, fleets have adapted their procurement and disposal strategies.
According to Brendon Green, General Manager Automotive Solutions at Pickles, the current surge in EV demand has clear historical parallels, even if the speed of change feels unprecedented.
The 2008 Fuel Shock: When Fleets Downsized Overnight
One of the most relevant comparisons comes from the late 2000s, when fuel prices surged and buyers rapidly shifted away from large sedans.
At the time, fleets and private buyers moved from traditional six-cylinder vehicles such as Commodores and Falcons into smaller, more fuel-efficient cars. It was a structural shift in vehicle preference driven by operating cost pressure rather than technology innovation.
Brendon said that period remains the closest historical reference point for what is happening today.
Brendon Green, General Manager Automotive Solutions at Pickles, said the industry saw a similar behavioural change when fuel costs last spiked.
“Everybody started to shift and move across into the smaller hatches and the smaller petrol cars. There was a big shift in what fleets were acquiring and therefore selling.”
The difference today is not the cause—but the speed.
“Nothing accelerated like this. It just was over time. This has really just been ignited by fuel spiking.”
For Fleet Managers, the lesson is familiar: when operating costs change quickly, vehicle demand changes quickly too.
The GFC and COVID: Used Vehicles Become the Safe Option
Another pattern from history is the surge in used vehicle demand during periods of economic uncertainty.
During both the Global Financial Crisis and the COVID disruption, buyers prioritised affordability and liquidity. Rather than committing to new vehicle purchases, organisations and households sought to control spending by moving into the used market.
Brendon noted that this behaviour remains consistent.
“Used vehicles become a flavour because people want to control their spend and get money in the bank and focus in on used vehicles.”
However, he emphasised that the current surge in used EV demand is more extreme than anything seen during those previous downturns.
“We’ve seen spikes in used vehicles through challenging economic times… but nothing to this extreme where it’s just an absolute hockey stick in reaction.”
That distinction matters for fleet planning. This is not simply a cyclical market response—it may represent a structural change in vehicle demand.
The Current Shift: From Fuel Efficiency to Fuel Independence
What makes the current market different from previous transitions is the objective of buyers. In the past, fleets moved to smaller vehicles to reduce fuel consumption. Today, many buyers are seeking to eliminate fuel costs altogether.
Brendon said cost-of-living pressures are the dominant driver behind the surge in EV demand.
“Customers are trying to control the cost of living and tap into low fuel costs and low maintenance costs.”
This shift from fuel efficiency to fuel independence is reshaping the used vehicle market. Recent market activity reflects this change:
- Record monthly EV sales volumes
- Significant increases in website searches and buyer registrations
- Faster selling times for used EVs
- Rising resale prices for key models
These indicators suggest that demand is being driven by operational economics rather than environmental messaging.
Price Signals: EV Values Are Moving Up, Not Down
For many Fleet Managers, the biggest concern over the past few years has been residual value risk. Early EV adopters experienced sharp depreciation, creating uncertainty in replacement planning and lease pricing models. The recent market movement suggests that risk profile may be changing.
Brendon said prices for some EV models have already begun to rise.
“On Model 3 Teslas, in the last two weeks we’ve seen them jump up by $10,000 to $12,000 in price.”
At the same time, traditional vehicles have stabilised rather than collapsed. Diesel vehicles remain resilient, while petrol vehicles are showing slightly softer demand. Importantly, overall sales volumes remain steady.
This indicates a rebalancing of demand rather than a decline in the broader used vehicle market.
What History Suggests About the Next Phase
Historical market shifts tend to follow a predictable pattern:
- Operating costs rise
- Buyers change vehicle preferences
- Fleet procurement strategies adjust
- Residual value assumptions stabilise
The current EV surge appears to be following the same trajectory. Brendon believes the growing number of EV buyers will ultimately support stronger resale performance over time.
“The buyer base is growing, and that should in turn create more competition on used EVs long term and therefore help to retain more price from a residual value standpoint.”
For Fleet Managers, this has direct implications for:
- Replacement timing
- Lease rate modelling
- Residual value forecasting
- Disposal strategies
The Strategic Takeaway for Fleet Managers
History shows that vehicle demand shifts are rarely permanent—but they are rarely random either. They are driven by cost pressures, technology availability, and buyer confidence.
Today’s surge in used EV demand sits at the intersection of all three. Fuel prices have increased operating costs. EV technology has matured. Buyer confidence has improved.
Together, those factors are creating a market environment that feels new—but follows a pattern the fleet industry has seen before. The key difference this time is speed.
- Kia PV5 review: An electric van that feels ready for work
The Kia PV5 arrives with an unusual job to do. It has to convince businesses that an electric van can deliver the practicality expected from a commercial vehicle while also offering the quieter, smoother driving experience that comes with an EV. After driving the PV5 at its Australian launch, the first impression is that Kia - Kia EV6 Air review: My heart says yes, but my fleet brain says noThe Kia EV6 is one of those cars I had almost forgotten about. That sounds harsh, because when the EV6 arrived in Australia in 2022 it was one of the most interesting electric cars on the market. It looked different, it drove properly, and when the EV6 GT started lining up against supercars in drag
- LDV Deliver 7 LWB Review: After The First 1,890kmWhen Port Hedland Air Freight Director Dominic Barlow needed another van for the business, he wasn’t looking for something to impress on a short test drive. He needed a vehicle that could earn its keep. After buying an LDV Deliver 7 LWB in Perth and driving it 1,890 kilometres north to Port Hedland, he shared
- Geely Starray EM-i review: Big on space, strong on value and easy to live withThe Geely Starray EM-i arrives in Australia with a fairly simple proposition: give buyers the smoothness and convenience of electric driving around town, add a petrol engine for longer journeys, wrap it all in a roomy SUV and keep the price within reach of mainstream buyers. After spending time with the Starray EM-i around Sydney
- Toyota HiLux BEV off-road review: The quiet achiever goes bushThere is something faintly suspicious about climbing a rocky hill in a HiLux and hearing almost nothing. Normally, a serious off-road climb has a soundtrack. There is diesel revving, tyres scrabbling, a little gravel being aggressively relocated and someone in the passenger seat asking whether that rock was meant to be there. The Toyota HiLux
