The recently released ANCAP safety rating for the Kia K4 sedan has delivered a clear message for fleet managers: relying solely on star ratings when assessing vehicle safety is no longer enough.
ANCAP awarded the Kia K4 Sport, Sport+, GT-Line and S with the optional Safety Pack a five-star rating, while the base S variant without the pack scored just four stars. The drop is largely due to the omission of critical crash avoidance features – especially autonomous emergency braking (AEB) functionality that fails to detect cars in cross traffic scenarios or motorcycles in adjacent lanes.
In an era where ANCAP ratings are used as a fleet-policy baseline or procurement filter, this dual outcome highlights a pressing issue: variant-specific safety differences are becoming more common and more complex. Manufacturers, under pressure to meet competitive price points, are stripping out safety technology from base variants, often to attract price-conscious buyers.
A New Layer of Risk
The Kia K4 S without the Safety Pack still includes a suite of passive and some active safety features. But its reduced Safety Assist score (64% vs 77% in other grades) reflects a diminished ability to avoid crashes in real-world driving scenarios. While these differences may seem minor on paper, they can be critical in protecting employees, contractors or volunteers – especially when the vehicle is used in busy metro traffic or shared as a pool car.
This problem isn’t unique to Kia. Many brands are offering “stripped” versions of popular models to maintain sharp driveaway pricing. And from a procurement perspective, fleet managers may unintentionally specify a lower grade to meet budget targets without realising the safety compromise.
The Fleet Safety Conversation Needs to Expand
Organisations must now go beyond the star rating and dig deeper into variant-specific safety specifications. The ANCAP score is still important – but it is no longer the full story.
What’s needed is a broader, vehicle-agnostic safety policy that applies across all vehicle types in the fleet, including:
- Novated lease vehicles, which may be selected based on price or spec without fleet oversight.
- Grey fleet vehicles, where employees use personal cars for work travel.
- Tool-of-trade and pool vehicles, which are often shared among staff with varying driving habits.
- Short-term rental vehicles, which are frequently used to plug operational gaps.
Organisations should define minimum safety requirements based on key technologies, such as AEB with pedestrian/cyclist detection, lane keep assist, rear cross traffic alert, and blind spot monitoring – not just the star badge.
As ANCAP CEO Carla Hoorweg noted: “In 2025, safety should not be treated as a ‘pay-for’ option ”. And yet, that’s precisely the situation fleets are being forced to navigate.
What You Can Do
- Review your fleet policy to include minimum safety tech – not just an ANCAP rating.
- Educate buyers, especially those using novated leasing, about safety equipment differences.
- Ensure procurement teams understand how to interpret variant specs and include Safety Packs where needed.
- Engage suppliers and OEMs to confirm standard inclusions, especially when models change.
Ultimately, if the goal is to ensure all staff get home safely – regardless of the vehicle they drive – then the responsibility must shift from trusting star ratings to embedding safety into every fleet decision.
- How to Evaluate if You Should Outsource Fleet Management Tasks
When organisations review their fleet operations, the conversation often centres on financial models like leasing versus owning. But there’s another, equally important decision that can significantly impact performance: whether to outsource certain fleet management tasks. Outsourcing can deliver real value when applied correctly — but if misunderstood, it can create inefficiencies and strip the organisation - Leasing vs Owning: What’s the Best Financial Choice for Your Organisation?When it comes to managing fleet assets, one of the biggest decisions organisations face is whether to lease or own their vehicles and equipment. It’s a financial decision that has long-term impacts on cash flow, balance sheets, and overall business performance. But before you can make the right choice, it’s essential to have a clear
- Why Grey Fleet Must Be Included in Your Fleet PolicyWhen organisations think about fleet management, their focus is typically on the vehicles they own, lease, or operate directly. However, one significant area often overlooked is the grey fleet — vehicles owned and driven by employees to perform work-related tasks. Grey fleet is a growing blind spot for many organisations. It is a real and
- Why Updating Your Fleet Policy is EssentialThe workplace has changed dramatically since the COVID-19 pandemic, and fleet management is no exception. Flexible work arrangements, increased focus on employee safety, and new service delivery models mean that many organisations are using their vehicles very differently compared to just a few years ago. In this new environment, having an up-to-date, clearly defined fleet
- The Key to Smarter, Safer and More Cost-Effective Fleet ManagementManaging a fleet is one of the most complex tasks an organisation can face. Whether your business operates 20 vehicles or 2,000, the challenges of compliance, cost control, and operational efficiency are constant. Many organisations fall into a pattern of simply maintaining the status quo, missing valuable opportunities for improvement. This is where the expertise
